Skip to main content

Underinsurance gaps in strata: what owners and managers should know

A strata building can be insured and still be underinsured - with a gap between the amount on the policy and what it co cost to rebuild after a major loss.

That gap can grow over time. Rebuild costs change, buildings are renovated and fixtures are updated. An older valuation may no longer reflect the property as it stands today.

For owners and strata managers, the question is not simply whether insurance is in place, but whether the building sum insured still reflects the true cost of reinstating the insured property.

What you should know about underinsurance

An underinsurance gap can arise when the amount available under a policy is lower than the amount needed to rebuild, repair or replace insured property after a loss.

Insured values can also fall behind changing rebuild costs. If declared values haven’t been reviewed recently, there’s a real risk your cover hasn’t kept pace and the impact may only become clear when a claim happens. If the amount available under the policy is not enough, owners may face a financial shortfall.

Replacement value is important, if buildings are insured below this figure, owners could face major shortfalls at claim time.

How can an underinsurance gap happen?

One common cause is carrying the same building sum insured forward year after year without checking whether the replacement cost has changed. Renovations can also compound the issue - updated fixtures, plant and other building improvements may increase the amount needed to reinstate the property.

Market value can also create confusion. A property's sale price and its replacement value measure different things, and using one as a replacement for the other can leave a gap.

It’s also worth remembering rebuilding can involve more than just construction. Costs may include demolition, debris removal and professional fees such as architects, engineers and surveyors.

All of this is why reviewing the basis used to calculate the building sum insured matters at each renewal.

Building valuation rules vary across Australia

There is no single valuation rule that applies to every strata scheme across Australia. Requirements and government guidance differ between jurisdictions and scheme types.

For Queensland bodies corporate that are required to insure one or more buildings, an independent valuation must be done at least every 5 years.

In Victoria, a prescribed owners corporation must “obtain a valuation every five years of all buildings that it is required to insure.”

These differences are a useful reminder to check the requirements that apply to your own scheme and location.

What could happen at claim time?

If an insured loss costs more to repair or rebuild than the sum insured, there may be a financial gap which falls on the owners. The outcome will not necessarily be the same under every strata policy - limits, conditions and claim settlement provisions can differ.

This is why the policy schedule and wording need to be read together, rather than relying on the headline sum insured figure alone.

What should owners and managers review?

Renewal is a useful time to check whether the property and its insured values still line up. Start with the latest building valuation and consider what has changed since it was completed.

A review can include:

  • The current building sum insured
  • Renovations, additions and updated fixtures
  • The basis used to calculate replacement value
  • Relevant policy limits and sub-limits
  • Whether a new professional valuation is due

If something significant changes during the year, it may also be worth reviewing the values insured before the next renewal.

Need help?

If you have questions about insured values, valuations or your strata insurance arrangements, speak with your Marsh risk advisor.

Frequently asked questions

An underinsurance gap can arise when the amount available under the policy is lower than the insured cost of repairing, rebuilding or replacing property after a loss.

Review the current building sum insured, the latest valuation and any significant changes made to the property since that valuation. A professional valuation can also help establish current reinstatement values.

No. Market value relates to a property's sale value. Replacement value relates to the cost of rebuilding or reinstating insured property.

There is no single Australia-wide interval. Requirements and government guidance vary between jurisdictions and scheme types.

NSW Government guidance says: “You should get a new building valuation every 2 to 5 years by contracting a qualified valuer.”

Where the body corporate has to insure one or more buildings, the Queensland Government says: “An independent valuation must be done at least every 5 years.”

Consumer Affairs Victoria says a prescribed owners corporation must “obtain a valuation every five years of all buildings that it is required to insure.”

They can affect the amount needed to reinstate a building. Significant renovations, additions and changes to fixtures should be considered when insured values are reviewed.

This depends on the scheme, policy and circumstances of the loss. Where the amount available under the policy is insufficient, owners may face additional costs.

Not necessarily. Any catastrophe cover is subject to the individual policy terms, conditions and limits. It should be considered alongside the underlying building sum insured.

Not necessarily. Renewal is a useful review point, but significant changes to a property during the year may also be a reason to revisit insured values.

A strata manager can help raise valuation and underinsurance matters for review. Their responsibilities will depend on the scheme, their appointment and the jurisdiction.

References

  1. Queensland Government, “Building insurance and valuation”, https://www.qld.gov.au/housing/body-corporate/finance-insurance/insurance/building, accessed on 21 August 2026.
  2. Consumer Affairs Victoria, “Insurance – owners corporations”, https://www.consumer.vic.gov.au/housing/owners-corporations/finance-insurance-and-record-keeping/insurance, accessed on 21 August 2026.

This publication is not intended to be taken as advice regarding any individual situation and should not be relied upon as such. The information contained herein is based on sources we believe reliable, but we make no representation or warranty as to its accuracy. Marsh shall have no obligation to update this publication and shall have no liability to you or any other party arising out of this publication or any matter contained herein. Any statements concerning actuarial, tax, accounting, or legal matters are based solely on our experience as insurance brokers and risk consultants and are not to be relied upon as actuarial, accounting, tax, or legal advice, for which you should consult your own professional advisors. Any modelling, analytics, or projections are subject to inherent uncertainty, and any analysis could be materially affected if any underlying assumptions, conditions, information, or factors are inaccurate or incomplete or should change.

LCPA 26/3921